Live wire

Delhi Police Tells Supreme Court Influencers Are Not Journalists at Protests

Its affidavit on October's anti-CEC protests defends the 5 October guidelines and denies detaining or harassing journalists.

Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that content creators, reel-makers and social media influencers carrying cameras and microphones should not be treated as bona fide journalists under its guidelines for covering protests, in an affidavit filed by a joint commissioner. The affidavit responds to petitions that allege police manhandled, harassed and detained journalists covering October's demonstrations against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, including protests on 3 and 11 October and one at Connaught Place. The petitioners are journalists' and press freedom bodies.

The guidelines

The police say their guidelines of 5 October advised journalists to carry identity cards from their media organisation or a government accreditation card, keep them visible, avoid obstructing police and keep a safe distance. They say accreditation is not required and an employer's card is enough, and that the guidelines were facilitative and not restrictive. They say the Supreme Court's order of 11 October protected bona fide journalists and not influencers or unruly elements, and that Press Council guidelines of 15 October are substantially similar to their advisory. They argue that the presence of influencers made it hard to identify real journalists in crowds.

Allegations denied

The police deny detaining journalists, saying those released were removed briefly for verification, and cite cases in which journalists were later allowed to work or released within about 45 minutes. They deny seizing cameras or phones. They deny the sexual harassment allegations as uncorroborated: of four complaints, three were closed after complainants did not pursue them, and the fourth was not backed by surveillance footage, with a magistrate's court seeking an action taken report and the matter listed for 1 December. A case against a woman journalist under the law on atrocities against scheduled castes and tribes has been moved to the Crime Branch, and police say no coercive action has been taken on the court's directions.

The police say 3,747 women officers were deployed on the day shift and 664 on the night shift. The report carried no ruling and no date for the Supreme Court hearing. These are the police's statements and have not been tested by the court.

Topics